Is Organic Dog Food Better?

Is Organic Dog Food Better?

Posted by Lianne McLeod D.V.M. on

Is Organic Dog Food Better?

Is organic dog food better, or is it another marketing strategy to attract health-conscious pet owners? To comprehend whether organic dog food is superior, it's essential to understand what makes it different from conventional options.

Organic food proponents argue that it offers higher nutrient density compared to non-organic alternatives. The absence of synthetic additives in organic food is believed to preserve the natural nutritional profile of ingredients, providing dogs with a more wholesome diet.

Additionally, advocates for organic dog food also emphasize its positive environmental impact. Organic farming practices typically prioritize soil health and biodiversity, aiming to minimize the use of synthetic chemicals that can harm the environment

This article will explore the potential benefits, drawbacks, and overall breakdown of organic foods for dogs.

Pros of Organic Pet Food

certified organic

These organic foods are produced using natural ingredients and follow specific standards and regulations set by organic certification organizations. The term "organic" refers to how agricultural products are grown and processed.

It is designed to provide animals with a diet free from synthetic additives, pesticides, herbicides, growth hormones, genetically modified organisms (GMOs), and other prohibited substances. The main pros of organic dog food include:

Organic Ingredients

The ingredients found in an organic diet can be split into two distinct categories:

  1. Plant-Based Ingredients - This includes organic fruits, vegetables, and grains that are grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers.

  2. Organic Meat - The meat used comes from animals that are raised following organic farming processes. This typically means the animals are given organically grown foods, have access to the outdoors, and are not treated with antibiotics or synthetic hormones.

No Synthetic Additives

Healthy dog food avoids the use of synthetic additives such as artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives. Instead, natural alternatives are often used to enhance the taste and appearance of the food.

Non-GMO Ingredients

Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are not allowed in organic pet foods. This ensures that the ingredients used in the food are not genetically engineered.

Humane and Ethical Practices

These farming practices emphasize the humane treatment of animals. Animals used for their meat are typically raised in conditions that prioritize their well-being, such as access to the outdoors and the absence of confinement or overcrowding.

Environmental Sustainability

Organic farming aims to promote environmental sustainability. This includes practices that support soil health, and biodiversity, and avoid the use of synthetic fertilizers that can be harmful to the environment.

Certification

To be labeled as natural, the product must meet the standards set by organic certification organizations. These organizations, such as the USDA Organic in the United States or similar bodies in other countries, have specific criteria that producers must adhere to in order to achieve and maintain organic certification.

Nutritional Balance

Natural canine food is formulated to provide a balanced and complete diet. This includes the essential nutrients required for a dog's overall health, such as proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals.

Limited Processing

While some processing is necessary to create food for pets, natural varieties typically undergo minimal processing to preserve the natural integrity of the specific ingredients.

Organic Dog Chews

organic dog chews

Dog chews are not only a source of entertainment for our canine companions but also contribute to their dental health and overall well-being. The following factors set these chews apart from conventional options:

  • Natural Ingredients: They are crafted using natural ingredients, avoiding artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. This is especially crucial for any dog with sensitivities or allergies to certain additives commonly found in nonorganic chews.

  • Health Benefits: Organic chews often include ingredients that provide additional benefits. For example, some chews incorporate herbs or supplements known for their positive effects on joint health, skin, or coat condition. This dual-purpose approach addresses not only the dog's need for entertainment but also contributes to their overall health.

  • Dental Health: This is a significant concern for pet parents, and organic dog chews can play a role in addressing this issue. Chews made from natural ingredients may help reduce plaque and tartar buildup, promoting healthier gums and teeth. Additionally, the act of chewing itself can contribute to better dental hygiene by reducing the risk of periodontal disease.

Organic Dog Oils

organic oil image

The inclusion of oils in a dog's diet is gaining popularity for its potential health benefits. Organic dog oils, derived from various sources, are believed to offer advantages over their non-organic counterparts for the following reasons:

  • Omega-3: One of the primary reasons canine parents incorporate oils into their pet's diet is for the omega-3 fatty acids they contain. These essentials play a crucial role in supporting a dog's immune system, promoting a healthy coat and skin, and contributing to overall cardiovascular health. Organic oils, sourced from fish or plants, are often touted as having a more natural and bioavailable form of these fatty acids.

  • Reduced Contaminant Risk: Concerns about contaminants such as pesticide residues and mercury in fish oil have led some canine parents to opt for organic sources. Organic fish oils are typically purified to remove potential toxins, providing a cleaner and safer option for your dog. Similarly, plant-based natural oils like flaxseed oil are free from the contaminants associated with pesticide exposure.

  • Ethical Sourcing: Organic oils often come from ethically sourced ingredients. This means that the animals or plants from which the oil is derived are raised or grown in humane and sustainable conditions. For canine parents who prioritize ethical considerations in their purchasing decisions, this is a compelling reason to choose natural oils for their furry friends.

lolahemp banner

Organic Doesn't Always Mean Healthier

Although natural dog food has gained popularity for its emphasis on high-quality and ethically sourced ingredients, it's important to recognize that being labeled as "organic" doesn't automatically guarantee that a brand is healthier.

The following factors contribute to the understanding that an organic label isn't always healthier than nonorganic food:

Nutritional Content Varies

Natural pet foods vary significantly in their nutritional content. While they often feature quality ingredients, the overall nutrient profile may still differ, and not all options provide the optimal balance of essentials for every canine.

2. Ingredient Quality Versus Formulation

The quality of individual natural ingredients doesn't necessarily translate to a well-formulated and balanced canine food. Achieving the right balance of proteins, fats, vitamins, and minerals is crucial for a dog's overall well-being, and this goes beyond simply using natural ingredients.

3. Overemphasis on Marketing

Some brands may prioritize marketing their products as natural without ensuring that the nutritional composition meets the specific needs of our canine companions. A focus on marketing rather than nutritional science could lead to suboptimal formulations.

4. Additives and Processing

Just like with humans, even within the world of natural dog food, the extent of processing varies. Some natural-based brands still contain additives, and the processing methods employed may impact the overall nutritional value.

5. Caloric Density

Caloric density is a critical factor in nutrition. Natural dog food may not always address the specific caloric needs of an individual canine, leading to potential overfeeding or underfeeding.

6. Individual Needs

Canines have unique dietary requirements based on factors such as age, breed, size, and health conditions. A one-size-fits-all approach with natural dog food may not cater to the diverse needs of all canines.

7. Certification Ambiguities

The term "organic" has varying standards across regions. Certification labels provide assurance, but not all biotic foods may adhere to the same rigorous criteria. Some products may use the term loosely.

8. Cost Considerations

Organic canine food is often more expensive than unnatural alternatives. The higher cost doesn't necessarily equate to superior value in terms of nutrition, and dog parents should evaluate the overall value for their specific budget.

9. Transition Challenges

Canines transitioning from conventional foods to organic dog food may experience digestive upset. A gradual transition is essential to avoid potential gastrointestinal issues.

10. Preference and Palatability

Dogs have individual preferences, and some may not readily accept some natural formulations. Palatability is crucial to ensure your canine companion consumes the necessary nutrients consistently.

Do All Organic Dog Foods Have the USDA Organic Seal?

usda seal

No, not all dog foods that claim to be organic have the USDA seal. While it signifies adherence to strict natural standards, some brands of biotic dog food may meet similar criteria without obtaining the USDA-certified organic seal.

Factors such as sourcing, processing methods, and adherence to natural practices vary among brands. Canine parents should scrutinize ingredient lists, and certifications to evaluate the overall quality of natural dog food, even in the absence of the USDA seal, to ensure it aligns with their desired standards for their canine companion's diet.

Healthy Ingredients to Look for in Organic Dog Food

If feeding organic food to your canine companion is a consideration, look for these healthy organic ingredients to ensure a well-balanced and nutritious diet:

inspecting healthy ingredients
  • Natural Protein Sources: Look for high-quality, natural proteins such as chicken, beef, lamb, or fish. These provide essential amino acids for muscle development and overall good health.

  • Whole Grains or Grain Alternatives: Opt for whole grains like brown rice or quinoa, or grain alternatives such as sweet potatoes or peas. These are rich in carbohydrates for energy.

  • Organic Fruits and Vegetables: Choose foods with organic fruits and vegetables like blueberries, carrots, and spinach. These provide vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.

  • Healthy Fats: Look for sources of healthy fats, including organic oils like flaxseed oil or fish oil. These fats support skin health and contribute to a shiny coat.

  • Natural Preservatives: Avoid artificial preservatives and choose natural alternatives like tocopherols (vitamin E) to maintain the freshness of the food.

  • Chelated Minerals: Chelated minerals, such as zinc proteinate or iron proteinate, are more easily absorbed by your dog's body and contribute to overall mineral balance.

  • Probiotics and Prebiotics: Some organic foods include probiotics and prebiotics to support a healthy digestive system by promoting beneficial gut bacteria.

  • Limited Additives: Minimize the presence of artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Organic brands often use natural alternatives to enhance taste and appearance.

  • Omega-3 and Omega-6: Ensure the inclusion of omega-3 and omega-6, commonly found in ingredients like fish oil, for skin and coat health.

  • Limited Ingredient Formulas: For canines with food sensitivities or allergies, consider organic food with limited ingredient formulas to simplify their diet.

  • Organic Eggs: Eggs provide an excellent source of protein, vitamins, and minerals. Look for dog food that includes organic eggs in their formulation.

  • Antioxidant-Rich Ingredients: Ingredients like berries, sweet potatoes, and spinach are rich in antioxidants, which help combat oxidative stress and avoid health issues.

The Bottom Line

a vet examining a dog with a checkmark

The term "organic" in dog food signifies a commitment to ethical and sustainable farming practices. However, pet owners should approach natural pet food with a discerning eye, understanding that the term alone doesn't guarantee superior nutritional quality or suitability for all canines.

Thoroughly evaluating ingredient lists, nutritional profiles, and certifications, and considering individual needs remain crucial in making informed decisions about your dog's diet. Furthermore, consulting with a veterinarian will provide valuable insights into the best diet plan for your specific canine companion.

Finally, while the demand for organic food for dogs continues to rise, its limited availability remains a significant concern. The parallel surge in human consumption of natural resources places a strain on the production and distribution of organic ingredients for pet food.

As we strive to provide our canine companions with the best nutrition possible, humans must consider the broader implications of our choices on the environment and resource utilization. Balancing the growing appetite for organic dog food with sustainable practices is vital to ensure a healthier future for both our pets and the planet.

References

  1. Heinze, C. R. (2018, August 14). Organic Pet Food: Is It Worth the Price? [Blog post]. Tufts University Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine. Retrieved from https://vetnutrition.tufts.edu/2018/08/organic/

  2. Specific Veterinary Diet. (n.d.). Organic Food for Dogs. Retrieved from https://www.specific-diets.co.uk/dog/everyday-food/organic-food-for-dogs-1

  3. Ethical Pets. (n.d.). Organic Dog Food. Retrieved from https://www.ethicalpets.co.uk/organic/organic-dog-food

  4. Shastri, A. (2023, June 14). The Benefits of Organic Dog Food. Retrieved from Veterinarians.org. https://www.veterinarians.org/organic-dog-food/

  5. The Ohio State University Veterinary Medical Center. (n.d.). Myths and Misconceptions Surrounding Pet Foods. Retrieved from https://vet.osu.edu/vmc/companion/our-services/nutrition-support-service/myths-and-misconceptions-surrounding-pet-foods

  6. Burns Pet Nutrition. (n.d.). The Best Natural Ingredients in Dog Food. Retrieved from https://burnspet.co.uk/nutrition-blog/the-best-natural-ingredients-dog-food/

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

AUTHOR

Lianne McLeod, DVM, is a former writer for The Spruce Pets, contributing articles for 11 years. Before Dr. McLeod began writing about pet care, she worked several years in small animal practice. She has written extensively about the care and keeping of exotic pets and pet health care. She now researches water quality and chronic disease at the University of Saskatchewan. Lianne McLeod earned her Doctorate of Veterinary Medicine from the Western College of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Saskatchewan. She also received a Bachelor of Science degree in biology from Simon Fraser University. She continued her education and received a Ph.D. in Epidemiology from the University of Saskatchewan. Now, she splits her time between her family, research and writing about pet health for all the animal lovers out there.


The Importance of Probiotics for Your Pet's Digestive Health

Lianne McLeod D.V.M.
By Lianne McLeod D.V.M.

Dr. Lianne McLeod explores how probiotics can impact your dog's digestive health and gut health.

Read more

The Difference Between Prebiotics and Probiotics for Dogs

Lianne McLeod D.V.M.
By Lianne McLeod D.V.M.

Dr. Lianne McLeod explores the use of prebiotics and probiotics for dogs.

Read more